comScore
  1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Maude
  8. The Braiser

What's with the name?

Allow us to explain.

Winter Is Coming

Game Of Thrones Recap: The Ghost of Harrenhal


Editor’s Note: HBO’s Game of Thrones is kicking into high gear with episode five. We started to see some crazy stuff last week which, in turn, led to even crazier stuff this week. Find out what Amy Ratcliffe thought about this week’s episode as well as some thoughts on how things are changing from George R.R. Martin’s novels. Read on and let us know how you felt about it all in the comments! 

(Spoilers ahead of course, book talk is at the very end if you want to avoid it. Don’t forget to catch up with last week’s recap if you missed it!)

Season 2: Episode Five – The Ghost of Harrenhal

Remember that quote of Arya’s from trailers for this season? “Anyone can die.” Last night’s The Ghost of Harrenhal proved again that no character in Westeros is safe. And it did so right off the bat.

At Storm’s End, Renly offers terms to Catelyn. They’re actually reasonable, too. Robb can be King in the North if he swears fealty. But remember that disturbing shadow baby birthed last week by Melisandre? Well, it’s all grown up and it enters the tent and slays Renly. Brienne is heartbroken and when knights come in and try to apprehend her, thinking she’s the culprit, she cuts them down. Have I mentioned I couldn’t imagine a more perfect Brienne than Gwendoline Christie? She flipped from sorrow to rage to confusion without a bump. Catelyn is able to convince her to leave before more men show up. She cautions Brienne, “You can’t avenge him if you are dead.”

They aren’t the only ones fleeing camp. Littlefinger advises Loras and Margaery Tyrell to do the same. Loras is angry – he loved Renly more than Brienne – but his sister echoes Catelyn and says, “you can’t avenge him from the grave.” It draws an interesting parallel between the two pairs. Before they decided to take leave, Littlefinger elicits Margaery’s true intentions: she doesn’t want to be a queen, she wants to be the Queen. Interesting.

Stannis doesn’t seem the least bit shaken up about his brother’s death. Even though they were at war and Stannis was behind it, I would have expected to see a little remorse. Just a teensy bit. There’s nothing though. He’s focused only on winning the throne, and the next step is sending ships against King’s Landing. One reason Stannis keeps Davos around is for hard truths, and the Onion Knight delivers. The shocking part? Stannis listens to Davos’ council about not taking Lady Melisandre to King’s Landing. She’s a foreigner, and it wouldn’t be good if it looked like it was her victory. Smart guy, that Davos.

In King’s Landing, Tyrion can smell that’s something afoot. Of course, Cersei refuses to give him answers. So in a delightful scene, he tortures Lancel with words and threats. He learns Cersei is having the pyromancers create thousands of pots of wildfire, and she plans to launch them from the city walls. Wildfire can even burn through steel. The always astute Bronn points out a problem: it might defeat the incoming army, but it’s also likely to set King’s Landing ablaze. He had a bit of a Han Solo moment (yeah, I’m going to keep making comparisons to Star Wars whenever possible). He tells the pyromancer, “Men win wars, not magic tricks.” Wait until he hears about the shadow baby!

Over in Harrenhal, Tywin does a crazy thing. He admits he’s underestimated Robb Stark. Actually, it’s not so nutty. Tywin doesn’t seem the type to me to shy away from admitting when he’s been bettered. I know he’s a tool, but there are times when I respect him. When he sends Arya (who he knows is from the North) on an errand, she runs into a friend from the road to Castle Black: Jaqen H’ghar. She released him and his fellow prisoners from the cage and thus saved them from fire and death.

He tells her since she saved three men from the Red God, now the Red God needs three deaths. He will kill any three men she names. She chooses the Tickler, and she chooses quickly. I certainly see why she wants him dead, but it’s not the most strategic choice. Jaqen delivers, too. As with pretty much every other character, Tom Wlaschiha is a great choice to play the part of Jaqen.

I dislike Theon as much as I like Jaqen. He continues to be a smarmy jerk. None of his crew respect him, so after a nudge from his first mate to man up (more or less), he hatches a plan. He’ll attack Torrhen Square, and Winterfell will send its men to turn them away. That will leave Winterfell wide open. The attack happens, and up in the North, Bran does indeed send Rodrik and his men to Torrhen Square. Bran also has a dream that hints at an ominous future for those at Winterfell. He sees the sea pouring into Winterfell and flooding it despite it being hundreds of miles away.

North of the Wall, the brothers of the Night’s Watch push through the frozen lands to find Qhorin Halfhand and an ancient fortress of sorts, the Fist of the First Men. When Halfhand arrives, he tells them the Wildlings are following Mance Rayder and they’re preparing to go to war. He also reveals that Mance used to be a brother of the Watch. He plans to take a small team to go into the camp and kill Mance; he hopes it will make the Wildlings disperse. I think that’s a little naive. Jon volunteers to go with Qhorin, but you don’t really get a feel for why. To prove himself? To get out of preparing Lord Mormont’s meals? Mormont is pretty particular about his spiced wine. Whatever the reason, Qhorin agrees to add him to the team and Mormont gives his blessing.

Across the Narrow Sea in Qarth – make sure you pronounce it correctly – Dany is being doted upon by her host with fine gowns and fancy parties. She even receives an invite to the House of the Undying by Pyat Pree. It’s not too surprising that all of this is to woo her. Xaro shows off his wealth and asks for her hand in marriage. He knows she needs ships and men to invade Westeros; she wants the Iron Throne more than anything. You can tell Dany is tempted by the offer, too. Jorah strongly councils against it and speaks passionately about why she should be on the throne but that this isn’t the way to gain it. Dany sees what Xaro had to point out to her – Jorah loves her.

One final scene that I can’t skip: after Catelyn and Brienne are well on their way, Brienne brings up revenge again. Catelyn cautions her to wait, and Brienne offers to serve her as long as Cat doesn’t stand in her way when the time comes to bring down Stannis. It was just like the book, and it was an honest and moving scene.

After the slap-you-in-the-face beginning, I feel that the rest of the episode was more moving pawns into place. Done wrong, that can be boring. They played it just right though, revealing some secrets along the way and adding some twists to keep it interesting. I enjoy the heck out of little things like the way Bran and Osha interact, when Arya gives sword fighting tips to Gendry, and just how well every character is cast. Some of my favorite scenes from season one were just Varys and Littlefinger talking. We got tons of those wonderful character interactions tonight, and that’s almost enough for me. Almost.

Book Notes:

This episode varied in big and small ways from the book. Here are the points that stuck out for me:

  • Renly’s murder was more of a horror scene in the book. It was still jarring on the screen, but it wasn’t quite the bizarre, terrible event that came across in the book. Something fell flat (perhaps because he wasn’t struck in the throat?).
  • Loras was obviously sad over the loss of Renly, but in the book, he went into a crazy rage. His emotions overtook him to a point where he killed two other knights. That action is a huge deal – not much below Jamie killing King Aerys – and indicated the strong effect Renly’s had on him. It’s a big character defining moment, and I’m not sure why they altered it so much.
  • A smaller Loras change: he doesn’t believe Brienne did it. He very much thought she was the murderer in the book.
  • The credit for Melisandre not going to King’s Landing should actually go to Stannis’ knights rather than Davos. It was sort of a general consensus. I like that it landed on Davos in the show, as it showed that Stannis is still willing to listen to his council.
  • Though the Tickler is on Arya’s nightly list of people she wants to kill, she actually never names him to Jaqen. She chooses someone who thus far hasn’t been mentioned in the show.
  • Where the heck are Meera and Jojen Reed? I don’t see any casting news about them, so maybe they are being pushed to season three. I have a hard time seeing how the rest of this season will go without them.
  • There’s a lot of backstory and scenes with Qhorin Halfhand cut out. I understand why they did so, but it does set up the groundwork for Jon volunteering to go with him. It doesn’t seem so out of the blue.
  • Arya and Tywin never interact in the book, so that was all new. It was a brilliant, intense scene and felt like it could belong though.
  • Xaro does propose to Dany, but he doesn’t have a vault or offer wealth or support for the Iron Throne. I feel like this was added to give her the conflict of possibly accepting it.

Amy Ratcliffe is a freelance writer who wants Needle and needles. And maybe some dragons. She blogs a lot at geek with curves.

TAGS: | | |


  • http://www.facebook.com/david.schmitt#!/ David R. Schmitt

    man these episodes whizz by, but that’s a credit to the superlative acting and script. When I watch this show the hour just vanishes. One scene I’d like to add that was amusing was Sam’s chattering about the First Men’s history and his companions bemoaning the fact that he does.  Sam is so good to lighten the mood even when he doesn’t mean to.

    Also, Tyrion and Bronn are the best. The conversation in the streets of King’s Landing and Tyrion’s look of disbelief by being referred to as a “demon monkey” by the man addressing the crowd was priceless.

  • http://twitter.com/ThyHoopyFrood J.S. MacDougall

    http://www.makinggameofthrones.com/production-diary/2011/12/29/the-last-week-in-belfast.html
    I was also wondering what happened to Meera and Jojen Reed. I think this article stating the last characters in the final shot (Spoilers by the way…) pretty much tells us they are probably being cut from the show entirely. I find that disappointing because I love those two.

  • JM Z

    First off, I’m loving these recaps. Secondly, I haven’t read a page of the books, but I wasn’t puzzled by Jon wanting to join the fight. He’s a manboy of action. I would’ve been confused if he’d been content to stay behind while his brothers were getting bloody, to be honest.

  • http://twitter.com/manthebastard Joseph Stilwell

    The Tickler was the man who was killed. Arya says to Jaqen “The man who tortures everybody… I don’t know his name, but everyone calls him The Tickler”. Jaqen replies “That will suffice”

  • http://www.thenerdybird.com/ Jill Pantozzi

    She meant he isn’t one of the people named by Arya in the book for Jaqen to kill.

  • Anonymous

    At this point, I assume Osha is replacing Meera and Jojen. I don’t know the long-term affects of this decision, especially without hints from the books.

    Um, does anyone else find Jaqen hot? Please tell me I’m not alone…

  • John Wao

    -Loved Gwendoline Christie, she’s a great addition, that scene with Michelle Fairley was awesome
    -A man loves Tom Wlaschiha too
    -I think the Reed twins are being pushed back to season 3

  • http://twitter.com/EleniRPG Eleni

    I agree that the Renly scene wasn’t as cool as I was hoping. I think part of it was that we’d already seen the shadow at the end of the last episode. In the book, we don’t see Davos witnessing Melisandre birthing the shadow baby until after Renly has been killed, because she does it again to kill another obstacle in Stannis’ path. I can understand the necessity of cutting out that second assassination for time constraints, but it made Renly’s death scene less shocking and mysterious, because you already know what the thing is and where it came from.

  • Gretchen Lancour

    Isn’t it Jojen who dreams of the sea coming to Winterfell in one of his green dreams? Since Bran is the one who dreams it in the show, and Osha is a sort of reluctant interpreter I’d say the Reeds won’t make it to the screen.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=607464418 Rusty Patti

    Am I the only one worried that Arya’s recitation of Robb’s feats and the stare down of Tywin will be used as the genesis for his scheming of “TRW” in the series?

  • Anonymous

    Oh yes. :)))

  • Julia Edman

    when Arya gives sword fighting tips to Gendry, and just how well every
    character is cast. Some of my favorite scenes from season one were just
    Varys and Littlefinger talking. We got tons of those wonderful character
    interactions tonight, and that’s almost enough for me. Almost.

    http://www.host-italy.com/

  • Anonymous

    Bran is having Jojen’s green dreams. I’d be surprised if he’s casted.

  • http://www.thenerdybird.com/ Jill Pantozzi

    I thought that too, but then who is going to go with Bran and who is going to go with Rickon? Seems like they’re keeping Osha with Bran.

  • http://www.thenerdybird.com/ Jill Pantozzi

    You are not alone.

  • SusanHey

    Am I the only one who’d spazz the freak out if Meera & Jojen are completely cut? Please tell me I’m not the only one!

  • http://profiles.google.com/gnomer.denois Jill Oliver

     Exactly, Hodor has to go with Bran to carry him. Osha needs to be with Rickon because you can’t leave a 5 year old alone.

  • http://profiles.google.com/gnomer.denois Jill Oliver

    I’m a bit irritated that they have Jaqen say the Red God. He serves the nameless god/faceless god. Have we really already reached the point of “too many religions, one more god will confuse people”?

  • http://twitter.com/thremnir Nick Larter

    Jaqen cites the red god in the book too when this scene happens.  The point is not that the red god is Jaqen’s own, but that the guys in the cage would have burned to death (ie; been claimed by the red god) had they not been rescued.

  • Anonymous

    I figure that Osha will go with Bran, and the Grand Maester will survive and then go with Rickon.

  • Matt Moore

     I’m expecting Bran to meet Meera and Jojen early in season 3. Till then, Osha and his own prophetic dreams will serve :)

  • Matt Moore

     Yeah I found the shadow completely underwhelming, in an overall action scene sense as well as the omission of Loras’ rageout which was a decisive break with his ‘knight of flowers’ persona… which also undercuts his later character arc. Regarding the shadow, it feels like they’re doing the CGI too cheaply – CGI in a room where everyone is standing still is easier from a compositing perspective but makes for less of a feeling of urgency and mayhem…

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tamora-Pierce/1209655487 Tamora Pierce

    And what about Jon’t discovery of dragonglass arrowheads, daggers, and spearheads at the Fist of the First Men?  It’s a really important point, and it isn’t shown at all!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tamora-Pierce/1209655487 Tamora Pierce

     Of course he’s hot.  He’s got a white streak in his hair, a pouty lower lip, and a slinky voice.  What’s not hot?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tamora-Pierce/1209655487 Tamora Pierce

     You are not.  Bran needs those two!

  • Anonymous

    They haven’t left yet so they could do.
    Jon leaving “HEY guys look what I found!” Gives them to Sam….leaves with the Halfhand.

  • http://twitter.com/willb473 will

    The things that stood out to me were a couple more small changes in ideas… in the book the Wildfire was Tyrion’s idea, not Cersei’s that he took over, and same with Theon taking Winterfell… it almost seemed like Dagmar was leading him to it.